The Story of Immigrants, Factory Girls, Labor Unions, and a Deadly Fire that Changed History Description The story of the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire is multidimensional. The tragedy, which caused the death of 146 garment workers, highlighted many of the issues that defined urban life in turn-of-the-century America. These topics include, but are not limited to labor unions, immigration, industrialization, and factory girls working in sweatshop conditions in Manhattan’s garment district. March 25, 1911 became a benchmark moment in the Progressive Era that ultimately resulted in drastic changes in labor standards for factories across New York City, and later the nation. However, with the horrifying death toll, mostly young immigrant women, it is a story that highlights early 20th century labor activism, the power of big business, and the emerging voice of women, still silenced at the voting booths. Through this tragic event, we can learn about not only the women who died but the movement that they provoked and the conditions of labor that they forever changed. Objective Student will use primary and secondary sources to gain a richer understanding of women’s activism and how the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire led to changes in labor and safety regulations in America.
Prerequisites This lesson should be taught as part of a unit on the Progressive Era in the United States. Before beginning class discussion, students will read assigned articles that will inform the classroom discussion and activities.
Tell students to frame their assessment of each article in response to the following:
Classroom activity should not be scheduled until all readings are completed. Procedures Activity I Getting Started: Poll Students: What do they believe is necessary for a safe and comfortable working environment? Then, ask them to imagine working 16-hours a day with little pay and few, if any, breaks or safety regulations. They likely would work in an unsanitary factory, with extreme heat or extreme cold depending on the season. Encourage students to speak with a partner and then share with the class. Finally, ask students to discuss what upset them or surprised them from pre-lesson readings. Hook (10 Minutes): Divide students into groups of three and ask them to respond to the following quote in a think-pair-share format.
Extend this activity by assigning outside research on who Frances Perkins was and what her significance was in American history. Encourage them to use the following website: http://francesperkinscenter.org/resources/ Activity II (10 Minutes): Students will remain in their groups of three and discuss their response to the Homework Question from the homework:
How are their answers different? Next, open a class discussion and exploration focusing on the homework readings and the Query posed. Prompt students to discuss knowledge gained:
Activity III (30-40 minutes depending on class time): Students will remain in their groups of three. Each group will be given two primary source articles related to the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire from the Chronicling America collection at the Library of Congress. These primary source articles reveal the broad impact of the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. With the help of their classmates, each student will compete the graphic organizer relating the fire to the essential impact topics provided on the chart. Each group will share their consensus with the class. The entire class will listen to what each group has to offer based on their readings. Closing/Assessment (10 minutes): Quick-Write: Students will provide a quick-write exit card to the teacher. The exit card must finish the following thought: “Based on your many readings and discussions on the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire, explain how women were agents of change…” In assessing the assignment, punctuation and grammar are not essential. Students should focus write a detailed account reflecting on what they have learned from the readings and classroom discussion about the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. Students can participate by sharing their writing out loud with the class if they choose. All students must turn in their quick-write for a participation grade. Assessment / Homework For homework students will read about the reforms that were created in response to the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. They will be asked to read the article provided by the Cornell University website and respond on a discussion board to the following prompt: Why is reform necessary for democracy? Cite evidence from the reading and your knowledge of the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. Future Research / Resources Standard CORE STANDARDS: Common Core CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.11-12.7
C3
Which of the following statements assesses the impact of New York's Tenement House Law of 1901 on the 44000 tenements that existed at the time?Which of the following statements assesses the impact of New York's Tenement House Law of 1901 on the 44,000 tenements that existed at the time? It failed to change older structures because reform was not profitable.
Which statement describes living conditions in New York City's eleventh ward at the turn of the nineteenth century?Which statement describes living conditions in New York City's Eleventh Ward at the turn of the nineteenth century? Crowding was a serious problem in tenements.
How did the city of Chicago address its sewage problem around the turn of the century?In 1900, a massive engineering effort addressed Chicago's sewage contamination when engineers constructed the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal to reverse the Chicago River's natural flow from eastward to westward, thereby steering human and industrial waste away from Lake Michigan.
What was the purpose of the phenomenon that took shape in the United States in the late nineteenth century and came to be known as progressivism?What was the purpose of the phenomenon that took shape in the United States in the late nineteenth century and came to be known as progressivism? →Progressivism was an overlapping set of movements united by their common desire to combat the ills of industrialization and urbanization.
|